What Do Trees Have to Do With Golf?


On our way back from a recent round of golf, Fritz and I were discussing the way most golfers evaluate golf courses. We've had this discussion before, and it inevitably gets around to my heartfelt conviction that trees do not enhance the "golfing experience".

Most golfers in North America assume that golf is not golf without tree-lined fairways. If I am not mistaken, this is a bias created by a century of golf course design compliments of a relatively small number of trend-setting designers. In Canada, Stanley Thompson was the main man. His course designs can be found across the country, and inevitably they feature lush green (soft) fairways lined with majestic trees.

Of course there are many reasons for this, both practical and esthetic. For starters, eastern North America has lots of trees, and just as important, it is impossible to replicate the sandy turf of Scotland or Ireland in other parts of the world that do not share the same climate.

Nevertheless it struck me as a bit odd when on a recent trip to Saskatchewan we found the same type of fairways in that relatively dry prairie climate as we have here in our much more humid environment in southern Ontario.

What we have seen in first half of the last century was a progression from the use of native grasses in a place like St. Andrews or Dornoch, Scotland to the use of highly manipulated hybrids like bentgrass in Ontario, where the climate can (more or less) support them (with constant watering, of course).

But rather than using native grasses in the prairie or semi-desert settings of the North American western plain, course designers in those regions seem to have imported the ideas developed in the east. Especially the use of trees and non-native grasses.

One course we played near Elbow, Saskatchewan had water lying around from the overnight watering. This was in spite of the recent rainy period in the area. And while the greens seemed to be holding up well, they were typically left quite long and shaggy so they could withstand the inevitable dry spell that was just around the corner.

Seems to me there should be native grasses that would do better than this. Of course I could be completely wrong...

My point is that golf course design in North America has often created synthetic environments that alienate the golfer from the native terrain and turf. Which gets me back to trees...

To my way of thinking, that trees should come into play during a round of golf seems an unfortunate departure from the original way the game was conceived. Once you play a bit of links golf you realize that the game was originally meant to be played by running the ball along the ground. Like curling, that other Scottish obsession, the game represents an attempt to control the way the ball (stone) interacts with the course (ice).

In the first 100 years or so of golf in North America we have tried to take this element out of the game by making sure that the ground remains soft, that the grass is as green and lush as possible, and that there are as many strategically placed trees as possible to get in the way of our drives and approach shots.

On the other hand, trees are an important part of the native landscape in many parts of North America, so I would be contradicting myself if I said they should not be part of a "natural" layout in eastern North American. I am not advocating the "denuding" of the landscape in order to create a pseudo links-like environment. But trees should remain strictly in the background as far as I am concerned. Thankfully, this seems to be the way golf course design has been moving for the last 15 years or so.

From Golf Stories at Internetgolfreview.com

Visit the article section at Internetgolfreview.com for more golf stories, articles and golf travel features.

Rick Hendershot is a writer, avid golfer creator of the Linknet Publishing Network. For online advertising opportunities, visit Linknet advertising options.


MORE RESOURCES:

USA TODAY

This week in golf, at a glance
USA TODAY
The Northern Trust Open is next week at Riviera in Los Angeles, followed by the World Golf Championships-Accenture Match Play Championship in Marana, Ariz. Course: Royal Melbourne Golf Club, Composite Course (6505 yards, par 73).
Golf GlanceWashington Post
Tiger Ready For PebbleESPN
Woods offers solution against long puttersKansas City Star
CBSSports.com
all 483 news articles »


Austin American-Statesman

Five things we learned from the Waste Management Open
Yahoo! Sports (blog)
Nobody has time to sit down and watch four rounds of golf each week -- unless, of course, you watch TV for a living, and if that's the case, please email us your number. So in an effort to condense the tournament coverage for you into a few quick hits, ...
Golf news and notes, Feb. 3San Francisco Chronicle
WM Phoenix Open enjoys a successful 2012Tucson Citizen
Golf roundup: Palmer leads in PhoenixAustin American-Statesman
Salt Lake Tribune -bettor.com (blog) -Phoenix Business Journal
all 980 news articles »


Cleveland News - Fox 8

Golfer stabbed in the leg after trying to play through
Yahoo! Sports (blog)
As Carpenter lay suffering with a punctured femoral artery and massive blood loss, a member of the foursome called 911 and told the dispatcher that the victim had fallen "on a golf club or something." Carpenter was rushed to the hospital, ...
Golf Course Brawl Could Cost Man His LegCleveland News - Fox 8
Golf club brawl severely injures manUPI.com
Man Impaled By Golf Club: Clay Carpenter Faces Leg AmputationHuffington Post
New York Post -Fox News
all 39 news articles »


Scotsman

Sport - Golf:Commercialbank Qatar Master
FOXSports.com
Gusts of 35mph meant less than three hours' play was possible on the second day of the Commercialbank Qatar Masters in Doha - and the second leg of the European Tour's Middle East swing has now been cut to 54 holes. American John Daly was among those ...
GALLERY: Golf's strangest & most obscure trophiesScottish Daily Record
Golf: Paul Lawrie back in world top 50 after second win in QatarScotsman
Paul Lawrie Wins Golf's Qatar Masters in Doha for First Time in 13 YearsBloomberg
UPI.com -Golf Monthly -Irish Independent
all 375 news articles »


Longboat Observer

PDGA: Disc Golf's Charleston Ice Bowl Will Take Place February 11
Yahoo! Sports
This PDGA sanctioned C-Tier tournament is a part of the SCDGO Points Series and will begin on Saturday, February 11, with a check-in at 8:30 am, followed by two rounds starting at 10:00 am The event will be played at the Tidal Creek Disc Golf Course in ...
PHOTO GALLERY: Ice Bowl Disc Golf TournamentLongboat Observer

all 3 news articles »


ESPN

Top-ranked Yani Tseng ready to get season, new swing into action in Australia
Washington Post
“We have a good field this week and a great golf course. “The course is not long but you need to be very focused. Every shot. If you just miss-focus on one shot, you can get in big trouble. This week will be like a major course. You need to be smart, ...
World leader Tseng sets sights on more powerSydney Morning Herald
Australian Women's Open Golf 2012ABC Online
Tseng turns her focus to Open hat-trickBrisbane Times
ESPN -Bangkok Post -San Francisco Chronicle
all 228 news articles »


PGA Museum of Golf Speaker Series presenting Metropolitan PGA HOF member Jimmy ...
TCPalm
Metropolitan PGA Section Hall of Fame member Jimmy Wright will be the featured speaker in the PGA Museum of Golf Speaker Series at PGA Village in Port St. Lucie on Feb. 16 at 5:30 pm PORT ST. LUCIE — Metropolitan PGA Section Hall of Fame Member Jimmy ...

and more »


Bradenton Herald

Haney's latest: Crocs Golf with Hank Haney
GolfDigest.com (blog)
Hank Haney's entrepeneurial spirit does not end with the March release of his book, "The Big Miss: My Years Coaching Tiger Woods," or his golf academies. Haney is now in the golf shoe business. Crocs Golf with Hank Haney will begin its rollout on March ...
Crocs™ Golf with Hank Haney Named “Best New Product” at 2012 PGA Merchandise ShowBusiness Wire (press release)
Crocs' Preston Is Part Of The Award-winning New Crocs Golf With Hank Haney ...TheStreet.com (press release)
Crocs(TM) Golf with Hank Haney Named "Best New Product" at 2012 PGA ...MarketWatch (press release)
4-traders (press release)
all 9 news articles »


Marco Island City Council approves two mini-golf courses on first reading
Marconews
By CHERYL FERRARA MARCO ISLAND — If two miniature golf courses pass second reading, residents will not need to drive to East Naples to play putt-putt golf. On Monday, Marco Island City Council heard first readings on two mini-golf concessions to be ...

and more »


Golf outing raises funds for Susan G. Komen
NBC2 News
On Tuesday, 342 women will play golf for the fundraiser. Most of the money raised stays in Southwest Florida. "Breast cancer programs, health, education screening," said Janssens. They serve the underserved women of our community.

and more »

Google News

home | site map
© 2006